Native American tribes join environmental, recreation and hunting organizations to call for a moratorium on “fast-tracking” massive energy projects on public lands
05/15/2012 08:21AM ● Published by Steve
Ocotillo Wind Energy project map provided by Pattern Energy with inserts by Jim Pelley
(Ocotillo and San Diego, California)—An unprecedented coalition of environmental leaders, tribal representatives, off-road vehicle users, writers/artists, hunters, outdoor enthusiasts, community residents and legal spokespersons are calling for a national moratorium on “fast tracking” massive energy projects on federal public lands.
“This industrial wind project is symbolic of what’s wrong with the current federal fast-tracking process,” Terry Weiner, Imperial County Projects Coordinator for the Desert Protective Council, said of the Ocotillo Wind Energy Facility (OWEF), the first big energy project in our region poised for destruction of public lands. “We are the canaries in the coal mine. If this is not stopped here, destruction of millions of acres of public lands across the southwest will likely soon follow.”
Imperial County’s Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors approved construction of the massive Ocotillo Wind Energy Facility (OWEF) by San Francisco-based Pattern Energy on 12,500 acres of desert surrounding the rural community of Ocotillo--despite compelling testimony and pleas by tribal members, residents and environmentalists to deny it.
Similar projects are in the pipeline on San Diego County’s scenic and cherished public lands, and others.
Industrialization of the 20 square miles of desert for the OWEF will cause irreparable impacts to fragile natural and Native American cultural resources, to the adjacent Anza-Borrego Desert State Park, to Ocotillo’s community character, quality of life and public health. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) is poised to make the decision to grant the developer, Pattern Energy, a right of way on previously protected land. Bulldozers could begin rolling as early as this week.
The federal renewable energy policy, authorized under the George W. Bush administration and now being implemented under the Barack Obama administration, for the first time, allows formerly protected national forests and recreation areas to be opened up for development as energy corridors. Additional remote solar and wind energy developments and long-distance transmission lines are in various stages of approval across America, including San Diego’s East County and Imperial County.
A new federal fast-track process intended to speed approvals of renewable energy projects has instead proved disastrous, shutting out parties with critical information and stifling voices of dissent.
“We believe that the Department of the Interior (DOI) is poised to violate the law and our rights to religious freedom and our cultural identities guaranteed by DOI’s own policies, the United States Constitution, and international declarations. We need your help,” Anthony Pico, Chairman of the Viejas band of Kumeyaay Indians, wrote in a letter to President Obama on February 22.
“This project will have devastating environmental consequences and cause irreparable harm to sensitive desert habitat, further endangering Peninsular Bighorn sheep, golden eagles and other wildlife,” said Ralph Singer, President of the Anza-Borrego Foundation. “Imagine 112 massive turbines, each 450 ft. tall -skyscraper height- with blades as large as a commercial jetliner wingspan. Yet impacts on Anza-Borrego Desert Park, which shares a 5-mile border with this project, were largely left out of the EIR.”
“I have done calculations on the wind speeds claimed and believe this project has relied on inflated numbers,” revealed Jim Pelley, an engineer and Ocotillo resident. “If true, then taxpayers are being defrauded and subsidies granted to Pattern Energy should be returned. I call on Congress to launch an investigation and on President Obama to order Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, who oversees the Bureau of Land Management, to halt this project pending outcome of a Congressional investigation with full public disclosure.”
"The BLM and Imperial County get a big fat F for failing to uphold their legal and ethical duty to protectsensitive resources, public health and safety, and taxpayers from boondoggle projects like this,” said Donna Tisdale, Secretary for the Protect Our Communities Foundation.
There are safer, cleaner options for renewable energy and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. According to the California Public Utilities Commission, PG&E now pays less for moderate-sized rooftop solar power ($114/MWhr) than for wind energy ($118/MWhr). PV solar is dropping to price parity or nearly so. Given the unreliability of the wind resource and vast hidden costs of wind energy’s harmful impacts, solar on roofs and parking lots in the already built environment is the cleaner, cheaper, more reliable option for the people of California.
Several organizations have indicated they are pursuing legal actions in hopes of halting the Ocotillo project. But the broader issue is the destruction of public lands soon to take place on a devastating national scale.
These are our precious public lands that are being plundered for private profit by corporations including big energy companies. The same industry that brought you the ENRON fiasco and Gulf oil spill is now implementing a massive takeover of our public lands.
The coalition will schedule a press conference after Secretary of the Interior Salazar signs the Record of Decision for the project. We will post that information when we receive it.
The Sun Runner Magazine opposes "fast-track" energy projects due to their exclusion of proper public comment and review, their trampling of Native American tribal sovereignty, and the lack of appropriate environmental review.
We oppose the Ocotillo Wind Energy project and believe it is inappropriately sited and will have a negative impact on wildlife, Native American cultural resources, local residents, recreational vehicle use, and the desert's tourism industry.
The Sun Runner has found that the BLM has a poor record of responding to public information requests, and has operated unethically, if not illegally, in this regard. The agency's record so far on fast-tracked projects, is an unmitigated failure to protect the public's interests in the management of lands belonging to the American people. These interests of the American public have decisively been subordinated to the interests of a government agenda to promote industrial power and the multinational corporations that will benefit from constructing their projects with taxpayer-subsidized federal loan guarantees and incentives, on almost free public lands.
The Anza-Borrego Foundation has more information on Anza-Borrego Desert State Park and the Ocotillo Wind Energy project. Visit at www.theabf.org.